VillageCraft Boards > Reports & Grievances

Village rule violation : CRH244

<< < (2/3) > >>

FroggyBee:
Waffles did break the rules that were in place at the time and we will deal with that. That is something we can talk to him about and make sure that rules in place won't be broken again. The rules that were on the board were changed every so often, but nothing in our rule book about PvP has been changed since this happened. I'm not trying to deny that there was a rule on the board saying that PvP has to have consent from both parties, but it's really hard to regulate everything everyone does in a village this big and with so many people who hang around all the time. Nobody else who started PvP in Ambrose without consent from the other party was punished because majority of the time it's not a problem.
That being said, two wrongs don't make a right and if there was really an issue with the non consensual PvP, you should have messaged a village owner. I do know that you were consulted with the person involved before this was posted and still refused to return the one item that was obtained through PvP inside the Ambrose limits. I'm trying to be very clear and consistent on our village rules and I would have rather this had been sorted out in game rather than here.

CRH244:
I would hardly call being constantly pestered to return the item as being 'consulted' by waffles. I would've preferred this be sorted out in game as well, but as you can see I didn't make that choice.

Kittypopping:
I came to you and asked you to give it back as an adult so we didn’t have to do this. You said no admitted to killing him at the courtyard and taking the axe and left it at that. The reason this is in forums to begin with is because a staff member advised us to post it here. You were given the option to sort this out when I reached out to try sort it out but you didn’t want to come to a conclusion there as you don’t believe you’re in the wrong for taking the item. I feel like you killing waffels was enough of a punishment, but taking an item that’s an event item and ignoring the rules of a person village isn’t fair. I even told you exactly what Froggy has just said. However you don’t think rules of a village should be enforced by staff which is why we’re here. You’re right this could’ve been sorted in game, however you didn’t want to.

Shensley:
My question is whether or not CRH is a member of this village. If he's not, he has no obligation to follow the posted rules of the village. You cannot force a player into a no keeps pvp if they did not accept and agree to it, that's just not how it works. Having a village with pvp on is a risky move as it allows any player to wander in and start attacking if they choose so, and again, with no requirement to give the items back. If you got everything back except for one thing I'd consider yourself lucky and move on. This was just my two cents, staff as a whole will post a decision asap.

Cbddallas:
The staff have discussed, and we are in agreement that under the rules, staff will only enforce pvp agreements, such as no keeps, when there is clear and specific agreement between the combatants prior to each incident or battle.  In the absence of an unambiguous and stated agreement between the players directly involved, enforcement is up to the village owner/s.

Villages with PVP enabled are treated the same PVP-wise as Outlands:

Under rule 10,
"Allowed:
- Fighting in the Outlands and anywhere else where PVP is ON is allowed.
- Fighting in uncommon Villages where PVP is ON is allowed.
- Fighting in Arenas is allowed.”

Navigation

[0] Message Index

[#] Next page

[*] Previous page